I'm leaving this blog post largely in the words of the various parties in their own words as to how they have responded to today's
judicial review on adoption here in Northern Ireland.
The DUP have nothing on their own website but speaking to the BBC the Health Minister
Edwin Poots has said:
"It is my intention to urgently appeal this judgment and I am taking this action with a heavy heart.
"I have already publicly declared my intention to reform
Northern Ireland adoption law because reform is much needed and long
overdue.
"This judicial review has already delayed plans to introduce a
new Adoption and Children Bill in the Assembly and I fear that this
will lead to further delay."
Sinn Féin said:
Sinn Féin MLA Sue Ramsey said she is disappointed by
the Health Minister’s decision to appeal a High Court ruling that a ban on gay
and unmarried couples is unlawful.
The West Belfast MLA and Chair of the Health Committee
at the Assembly said:
"This is a disappointing decision by the Health
Minister Edwin Poots considering that our laws on adoption where out of date
and not reflective of modern society and life-styles.
"The primary
focus when it comes to adoption has to be the welfare of the child. It has to
be the determining factor and guiding principle when it comes to anyone
adopting a child.
"A single
person or unmarried couple should be able to adopt a child, regardless of their
sexuality, providing they can provide a stable, caring home with the child’s
best interests at the heart of that decision.
"This extension of the eligibility criteria in line with modern society
will significantly reduce the number of children in care."
SDLP said:
SDLP Health Spokesperson Conall McDevitt has welcomed this
morning's ruling that the current bar on unmarried couples and civil
partners adopting is unlawful and has called for a legislative remedy.
The South Belfast MLA was speaking after Mr Justice Treacy's decision to grant the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission a judicial review into current arrangements regarding adoption.
He said:
"Mr Justice Treacy's ruling is very welcome and a
positive move forward towards creating uniform equality on adoption
across these islands.
"This ruling, however, is only one step forward. If full adoption equality is to be achieved and Northern Ireland’s arrangements are to be made lawful, in line with Britain, a legislative framework must be drafted and brought forward for ratification without delay."
The
Alliance Party said:
Alliance
Health spokesperson Kieran McCarthy MLA
has welcomed
the court ruling that stated that the ban on unmarried couples from
adopting was illegal. He said that this was great progress and would
allow unmarried and same sex couples to adopt.
Kieran McCarthy MLA said:
"This is a tremendous victory and a great
day for progress. The ban on unmarried couples adopting was illogical
and wrong. The only issue that should matter is the needs of the child
and not a blanket ban on certain groups from adopting. This is an issue
of equality, so I am glad that the correct decision was reached
"The previsous rules did not make sense. Only one member of an
unmarried couple could previously have legally adopted a child which
could have resulted in the other partner having no rights to the child
if the legal parent died.
"We have far too many children waiting to be adopted for us to be picking and choosing who we think should be able to adopt.
"This ruling will obviously result in unmarried and same sex couple
being able to adopt which I fully support. I would urge any unmarried or
same sex couple who believes that they would be able to provide a
stable home to a child to consider applying to adopt a child."
Traditional Unionist Voice have said:
Commenting on Treacy J's ruling in favour of same sex adoption, TUV Leader Jim All
ister said he was d
isappointed with the outcome and hoped the At
torney General and Department would appeal.
"There was, in my view, inadequate attention to the paramount benefit to the child of adoption within a regular family unit of a father and a mother and unwarranted equivalence of such to the unnatural setting of a same sex relationship. Once more we see the human rights mantra being exploited to further divorce the law from the moral expectations and norms of the society it exists to serve."
The Ulster Unionist have said nothing on their website.