The blog and musings of Stephen Glenn Liberal Democrat activist, blogger and three time Westminster candidate. Content © Stephen Glenn 2005-2026
Friday, 4 December 2009
Hit Me With.....My Precisous...ous...s.s.s
I just couldn't resist using this as the title of a post. Andy Serkis who brought Gollum to life in Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy is to play Ian Dury back to life in his next role in musical bo-pic Sex, And Drugs and Rock and Roll.
Does Salmond Need an Education in Revealing the Truth

On 5 September 2007 Alex Salmond told Holyrood categorically that the SNPs key election pledge of cutting class sizes for all children in Primaries 1,2 and 3 to 18 or less by the end of this Parliament.
However, it appears he may already have been in receipt of information for one of the education department's senior civil servants that stated that this worthy goal could not have been achieved for 8 to 10 years. That meeting had occurred over two months earlier on 2 July 2007 according to the minute that Labour's Iain Gray produced in yesterday's First Minister's Questions. Mr Gray is now saying that the First Minister is breaking the ministerial code which states that ministers must give "accurate and truthful" advise. This is one pledge that has been repeated over and over. But this is one of the most high profile and early examples that it may have occurred while fresh in the face of contrary advice.
Mr Salmond's spokesman said as way of defence:
"The information (from officials] in July 2007 was to the Cabinet secretary for education, not to the First Minister."
With my former civil servant in a Departmental role I want to say that is not a valid defence in this case. There are two perfectly valid reasons that this would not have excluded Mr Salmond from the loop of such information.
The first is that such a high profile minute would undoubtedly have copied in the Private Office of the First Minister: there are times that the bureaucracy and officiousness of the civil service works for the good. Someone there would surely have highlighted this point and brought it to the First Minister's attention. If not, Fiona Hyslop herself on a subsequent memo in the margin against such a statement would have highlighted that one of the key blanks to the manifesto in her area was unachievable. Having worked in a devolved department in Northern Ireland I know just how much and at what level these things would have been copied over to the OFMDFM (Office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister) this sort of meeting would have been one area that that memo was an automatic copy in, even the Administrative Assistant who delivered it would have noticed that as they were getting the document copied.
The second reason would be in cabinet itself. The cabinet meeting after receiving such advice I'm sure that Fiona Hyslop would have been briefed by her Permanent Secretary to raise that issue at the meeting. It would have been a crunch matter for her pre-cabinet minute briefing document, so when as most cabinets do, there is discussion of every member's policy areas she would have had this as probably one of her first two points, if not the top one.
The second reason is most serious. If Salmond does not run his cabinet, and it is only a small cabinet in such a way that Ministers aren't allowed to share their issues of the day with their colleagues he himself is clearly not capable or fit for the job of First Minister. As the Conservative's Murdo Fraser said:
"If true, this is an astonishing state of affairs and no way to run a country.
"Many will find it inconceivable that Alex Salmond was unaware his own senior education advisers had made it crystal clear the SNP's flagship class size pledge could not be delivered in the lifetime of this parliament."
From my knowledge of how the civil service works I would say as above that is is true. Further from my knowledge of how Ministers are briefed ahead of meetings with the First Minister it is also something that would not have been dropped for 2 months and would have been highlighted from numerous sources within their reading of the original memo with urgency to that level. Indeed I can well imagine they would have been several margin notes suggesting that the FM needs to be alerted to this (that is just the way civil servants are).
There are only three options:
- Either Fiona Hyslop failed to alert others of this advice. But the memo of the meeting exists so that is not true
- Or That advice failed to reach the office of the First Minister. Again there are too many civil servants who would have got hold of that information for someone not to have made sure that he did.
- Or that having received the advice in writing or in cabinet Alex Salmond chose to ignore it. It doesn't take a Sherlock Holmes the reject the improbable of the other two and come to the final conclusion.
However, from the picture above one effect of the demotion of Ms Hyslop is the formation of the West Lothian triangle. The two West Lothian ladies in this party Fiona and Livingston MSP Angela Constance are now seated behind the Linlithgow born First Minister.
Thursday, 3 December 2009
There Have Been Too Many Goodbyes....
Unlike some of the bloggers out there I may have developed a rhinoceros hide. One of my former partners said I was far more public a person than they could ever be, but then again come election time my address get's posted in the newspaper and outside all the polling places where I am standing. Add to that I'm on the doorsteps engaging with local people a lot of the time my words can be rejected or accepted to my face as well as in the comments section. But this is not the first tale I've heard of someone being hounded out of blogging and I wish Subrosa all the best and hope that her worse fears are just that fears and don't come to any reality.
Subrosa and I have often over the less than a year that she has blogged had debates in our various comments sections. We won't always agree on things after all we hold different political views but that like a large number of the other bloggers out there doesn't make them any less of a friendly face (even virtual) in the crowd.
There seems to be a current trend in trying to out anonymous bloggers, much like the ridiculous way that certain groups try to out individuals based on their sexuality or in the US for their stance on abortion. I can respect fellow bloggers preference for Anonymity, for the most part I respect that#, and providing they write a coherent argument to support their views I can respect them for that as well. I don't respect them using their anonymity to spread lies, unfounded rumours or the like. It does bring to mind one story about myself of someone (from the MSM) digging for dirt and thinking they had found it, only to realise it was no news at all, must regular readers can guess what that may have been about.
Anyway back on track, it is disgraceful that anyone should be tracking down bloggers who colour the diversity of our blogosphere in such a way as to cause a concern to that individual for their own and their families safety. As Subrosa wrote it is people who "crave from their perverted pleasure in manipulating the distress of others" whether in this way or through chat rooms should never be tolerated. Indeed is a far greater need within the cyber community that Lord Mandelvort's three strike implications for illegal file sharing. The actions of such people can actually hurt people psychologically and mentally more than anything else and is a form of bullying that none of us should have to put up with.
In conclusion I want to wish Subrosa a fond and sad farewell. Parting under such circumstances can bring nothing but sorrow, but I with you and yours all the best for the future. The same applies to Advanced Media Watch and some of the others who have recently departed.
Update: Sadly I note that the shutters are down on Subrosa's blog before I could go over there an make a comment in her comments.
* Sadly this link is now a dead end.
# The only exception is Tory Bear because he used double standards on that matter himself.
RBS Board Adopting SNP Tactics

The SNP tactic leading into budgets and was (until it actually happened) the same about votes of confidence in their ministers to resign en masse and cause a new election they thought. Well it appears that the Royal Bank of Scotland board are to take the same approach over their bonuses.
The bank is looking to pay £1.5bn* in bonuses to its investment arm up from £900m last year. The board says it needs to pay this money to keep its top personnel with them and to keep them incentivised. Saying they need to act in the interests of all shareholders, not just the major one, a bit much after how those same shareholders were treated in recent years. Personally many of the rest of us have taking lower pay rises, reductions, loss of overtime payments, loss of bonuses with the only incentive to keep a job during the financial crisis. However, the issue does raise the issue of what type of bank the RBS is.
The Government bailed out the bank not to protect the investment arm but to protect the banking interests of the ordinary clients of the banks and their savings and banking facilities. These had been put at risk by that investment arm and its casino banking practices. Lib Dem Treasury Spokesman Vince Cable has been one of the most vocal proponents for breaking up the banking sector so that the high street banking sector that is all that most of us every have direct concerns about is separate from the speculative nature of the investment banks.
I recall when I first started studying economics the two were discussed totally separately, but soon after banking regulation was relaxed to allow both aspects to be carried out by the same company. However, maybe it is time for the Government to go back to those earlier principle to shore up confidence in our high street banks, after all you don't find an insurance company operating in the same premises as a bookmaker.
However, the issue with the bonuses is that the banks and the bankers were bailed out at tax payers expense and the government is going to look to get the taxpayers money back at some point. To spend £1.5bn of it on bonuses to staff, especially when many of those who bank with them are still struggling to make ends meet is lording it over everyone. Indeed if any other company director in any other line of business were to get a bail out from someone taking over 70% of the business in an interim agreement the profit would generally go to paying back that investor, even their own share of the profits to get out of the control quicker.
*This equates to 25% of the £6bn profit made by the investment arm of the bank this year.
Wednesday, 2 December 2009
Would Iain Gray Please Define Elite
Devolution may have benefited "elite" groups more than the general Scottish population, Labour leader Iain Gray has said.
His comment came as he prepared to deliver a lecture on 10 years of devolution at Edinburgh University.
Mr Gray warned that politics must shift from "identity to values" - and hit out at the SNP's "obsession" with independence as a solution.
Now that makes interesting reading for a number of scores. One just under 80% of the time spent under devolution, Scotland has benefited from a Labour First Minister and many of the ministerial roles being held by his Labour colleagues. So while I think he is trying to be disparaging about the SNP he is also being very disparaging about his Labour colleagues and indeed the Lib Dems who shared power with them.
Secondly I wonder if the elderly who gained free personal care count as elite? Or those who get their eyes tests free? What about the various students from all walks of live who do not have to pay tuition fees in Scotland? OK I can see them ending up being part of the elite but not all of them started there and without than many of them would not have started a degree.
What about the whole population who will benefit from the targets and actions taken to make Scotland a greener place, a knowledge based economy and other such actions which benefit many not just the elite. There is also the smoking ban which was brought in to help those that had no option but to work in some of the lowest paid jobs from the effects of passive smoking.
Just what does the Gray man of Holyrood mean by elite, you have to ask oneself when so many benefits have come to Scots that Labour in England have yet to deliver or trailed behind with.
How Green are Our Copenhagen Delegates?

I see that Prince Charles is to 'attend' the Copenhagen conference on Climate Change. I say attend, he has been invited to make an address during the opening of the conference, in total he will be in the Danish capital for all of four hours.
Which asks the question how will he be getting to conference? Is this a flying visit in both the literal and figurative senses? Indeed how will anyone be getting there? Obviously some of the long haul delegates will have to fly, but with High Speed Rail links across Europe surely the Europeans should be making every effort to get there by using less CO2 and letting the train take the strain?
That is just what George Lyon Scotland's Lib Dem MEP and Simon Hughes representing the party at UK level are doing. Of the 38 UK delegates 19 of the 38 have so far confirmed that they will be flying. Why? Simon Hughes says his train ticket cost him £398, the cost so far claimed for travel with not all travel costs claimed by the delegation is £17,500 averaging £420. So no only is it costing the planet more in CO2 it is costing the taxpayer more as well.
Indeed it is estimated that the total CO2 cost of the conference will come to 41,000 tons, approximately the annual emissions of Morocco. Surely we should expect more of our own delegation. Indeed Eurostar give advise on how to get to Copenhagen by train. It is no more arduous that some trips made by Scottish MPs on a weekly basis for work. Yet somehow when we have a chance to do something practical as well as merely talking about it half our delegation at least are not looking into greener options.
As an aside I know that Prince Charles does his best to carbon offset his travel emissions, but how many of the other delegates will be doing so?
Sad, Yet IMHO, Wrong Move Charlotte
I think it is sad that she no longer considers herself able to call herself a Lib Dem blogger, though I notice that her membership of the party when it is due for renewal is still a matter of debate. I'm going to rise as probably one of her least likely champions for her to stay. There have been times when I have disagreed with the direction the party has taken, sometimes from the conference platform, sometimes in smaller groups and sometimes in my blog. One thing that I do appreciate is the diversity of opinion of our party which groups together around certain key, somewhat metaphysical aims. Freedom and Liberty can equally mean two entirely different things depending on where you see freedom and Liberty being need to be applied. That is why our party can have a debate and come out of it pretty much how the average person would appreciate it at the end of the day.
Charlotte states the mansion tax as one of the straws that has broken her particular camels back. However, when you look at what was originally proposed surely she would see the revamping as a success for her side of that particular ideological tug-of-war over what might broadly be described as my end of the rope. Of course the battle is not yet won by either side as this idea has yet to face the cauldron that is the conference floor.
Much as in my dreams I'd initially like all of the party to agree with my stance on everything, I know that before I'd wake up that would soon turn into a nightmare. I need the Charlottes of this world and this party to straighten me out at times and I guess that there may even be times, even if she doesn't admit it, that sometimes she needs the Stephens of the same groups to do the same for her. Then we'll haggle, lodge amendments, state our cases, debate and vote through what is best all round, I hope (though sometimes I do wonder at the time).
I don't have a Lib Dem section to my blogroll so I won't have difficulty in placing Charlotte. However, I do hope we can have debates for a long time to come both within conference as well as at the pubs on the edge.